Cassady SchillerBlog Front Page BlogIndependent or employed – Understanding the ins and outs of employee classification

Independent or employed – Understanding the ins and outs of employee classification



October 17 , 2018 | Posted by Lydia Ritze |

Independent or employed – Understanding the ins and outs of employee classification

With the rise of independent contractors in the new, shared economy, distinctions between employees and contractors are increasingly blurred. The tax implications of misclassification can be significant, and the IRS, the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) and even some states are weighing in on employee classification. Here’s a look at the issues.

Tax advantages

Businesses often prefer to classify workers as independent contractors. Employers are obligated to pay the employer portion of FICA taxes for employees, but not for independent contractors. They also must withhold income taxes from employee pay, but not from independent contractor compensation.

There are many other obligations associated with employees that make independent contractors appealing to businesses. But these two tax obligations draw the attention of tax authorities.

Useful questions

IRS guidelines say that no single factor typically determines whether a worker should be classified as an employee or independent contractor. Instead, the decision hinges on the “economic realities” test that attempts to distinguish workers who are economically dependent on an employer — and are thus employees — from those in business for themselves and therefore not economically dependent.

The following six questions can help you determine a worker’s status:

Is the work performed by the worker an integral part of your business? The more important the work is to your business, the more likely the worker is an employee. The work can still be considered integral even if it’s only one step in a process, it’s performed by multiple people, or it’s performed away from your place of business. For instance, most carpenters perform work integral to a construction company, even though they typically work outside the business’s office.

Does the worker have the opportunity to impact their own profit or loss?  If a worker can earn more by completing their job more efficiently or making business decisions, they are likely an independent contractor. An independent contractor can make business decisions such as deciding whether to hire employees or purchase equipment. The result of those decisions could be a profit or loss for the worker.

Has the worker “invested” in the work? A truly independent contractor will invest in his or her business, and the investment will go beyond simply purchasing tools needed to do the job. Workers who invest in substantial things like equipment and use them beyond the work at your company are likely independent contractors.

What role do the worker’s skills and initiative play? Just because workers are technically proficient at a task — say, installing and repairing cable services — it doesn’t mean they’re independent contractors. However, skilled workers who demonstrate initiative to operate as an independent business may be. Operating as an independent business generally means that the worker exercises business judgment, is in open market competition with other businesses, and is not economically dependent on an employer.

Is the relationship between the worker and your company permanent or indefinite? Many at-will employees are considered permanent or indefinitely employed — rather than employed on a project or contract basis.

What is the nature and degree of your control vs. the worker’s? A truly independent contractor will exert control over a meaningful part of the work and relationship with an employer. Indeed, it’s almost impossible for companies — due to client demands or regulations — to prevent contractors from exerting control over the work and relationship.

Possible penalties

The question of proper classification becomes urgent for employers in light of potentially harsh tax penalties associated with misclassification. Costs can be steep and may include back taxes and interest. Please contact us if you have questions about the classification of your workers.